Shirley Real Estate Search

Shirley Homes for Sale

Our website features the best Shirley real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Shirley real estate market? Sign up for a  Shirley Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Shirley Homes and Condos for Sale

$519,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3554220 MLS Shirley Tangiers BLDG.
Thoughtful Attention to Detail & with No Expense Sparred, This Renovated Franklin Model Ranch-style home located in the Tangiers Section of Shirley Boasts a Stunning kitchen that has been expanded by 12 feet Showcasing Quartz countertops, soft-close cabinets, a beautiful farmhouse sink by Sinkology with a Moen Indi Faucet; additionally large Andersen Windows looking out to the yard is the perfect addition!. Luxury vinyl plank flooring and rotating recessed lighting are featured throughout. The main bathroom has a deep soaking tub, porcelain tile floors & ceramic tile surround mood lighting added for your spa experience! The property also includes 3 Energy Star mini-split units, new Andersen windows, siding, gutters, and soffits for energy efficiency. Additionally, there is a new 200 amp Electric service & new wiring throughout, a Rheem indirect tankless water heater, a new 275-gallon oil tank, and a new Pierless Boiler with a Beckett Burner. The primary bedroom has been extended by 6 feet, providing more space for a brand-new ensuite and closet. A new laundry room has also been added. The driveway has been expanded to 20 feet and finished with a paver border New sliding doors off the kitchen lead to a new 12x12-foot paver patio, which opens to the park-like fenced backyard. If you're looking for a move-in ready home to relax and enjoy your surroundings, this is the perfect one for you. Don't wait too long, or you might miss out on this amazing opportunity.

40 Holly Lane, Shirley

$459,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 3554132 MLS
Welcome to your dream home in the desirable Tangiers section of Shirley! This immaculate 3-bedroom ranch offers a perfect blend of comfort, style, and modern amenities. Move-in ready and impeccably maintained, this home is ideal for anyone seeking convenience and charm in a fantastic location. Step inside to discover an inviting layout featuring a spacious living area bathed in natural light. The eat-in kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's delight, boasting ample counter space, modern appliances, and a cozy dining area perfect for enjoying meals. Adjacent to the kitchen, the formal dining room provides an elegant setting for hosting dinner parties and special occasions. This home is equipped with state-of-the-art solar panels, ensuring energy efficiency and significant savings on utility bills. The split central air conditioning system with heating and cooling offers year-round comfort, allowing you to enjoy every season in perfect climate-controlled conditions. A Pellet Stove is a great addition to heat your home comfortably. One of the standout features of this property is the full, unfinished basement. This versatile space offers endless possibilities for customization, whether you envision a home gym, a workshop, or additional storage. Outside, the private fenced-in yard is an oasis of tranquility. The rear deck is perfect for relaxing, barbecuing, and entertaining guests, providing a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. You and your pets will enjoy the safety and freedom of the enclosed yard, making it an ideal setting. The home also includes an attached 1-car garage And a Large Paver driveway that can hold 4 cars providing secure parking and additional storage. With a robust 200 Amp electrical system and a 4-year-old architectural GAF roof, you can rest assured that the home's infrastructure is modern and reliable. Situated in the vibrant Tangiers section, this property enjoys a prime location with easy access to local amenities, schools, parks, and transportation. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or looking to downsize, this delightful ranch offers everything you need and more. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Shirley. Schedule your private tour today and experience the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and contemporary living!

24 Pinetop Drive, Shirley

$519,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3553802 MLS
Coastal English Country Living Discover the coastal charm of this enchanting English country home in the Smith Point area of Shirley, New York. Perfectly situated a mile from Smith Point Beach and Marina, and just a few blocks from a bay beach with breathtaking sunsets overlooking Bellport Bay, offering a serene lifestyle. Built in 1945 and thoughtfully renovated in 2019, it exudes character and modern comfort. The home features a large bright enclosed front porch with wainscoting walls, original wide wood plank floors throughout, a fabulous country eat-in kitchen with farm sink, a welcoming open living and dining room with a large masonry river-rock fireplace and wainscotting walls, a full bath with a claw foot tub, three bedrooms (one with built in bunk-beds made of reclaimed wood from a brownstone) and a walk-up spacious attic/loft space. The property is fully fenced and enveloped with mature landscaping. Outdoor amenities abound, including a deck for lounging, a refreshing pool, a vegetable garden with a large potting shed, and an outdoor bathroom-perfect for rinsing off after a day of beach, surfing, or boating adventures. This home also includes a cozy guest studio, a pea graveled fire pit area, vibrant flowering hydrangeas and other blooms. Located just 66 miles from Manhattan and nestled between Bellport Village and The Hamptons, this Smith Point gem is a rare find. It offers the best of coastal living with unparalleled charm and convenience. Don't miss the opportunity to make this idyllic retreat your own! *Possible subdivision. See attached survey.

63 Saint George Drive, Shirley

$529,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 3553764 MLS
Welcome to this stunning, ORIGINAL owner, two-story dream home featuring 4 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms on a sprawling 0.5-acre lot. Built in 2014, this home includes many upgrades you will love, starting with an airy, open-concept living space. Enjoy the elegance of wood flooring in the living areas and tile flooring in the bathrooms, complemented by cozy carpeting in the bedrooms. The fully equipped kitchen is ready for your next culinary adventure, boasting wooden cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a unique tile backsplash. Overlooking the dining room is a large island, perfect for sipping your morning coffee as you start the day. Upstairs, you'll find 4 equally sized bedrooms, offering endless possibilities for sleepover guests, an at-home office, a nursery, a studio, and more. The primary suite features big windows with picturesque backyard views, a massive closet, and an en-suite bathroom with a relaxing walk-in shower. Outside, the expansive backyard becomes your personal wonderland. Whether you're enjoying a glass of wine on the patio while watching the sunset, playing basketball with the family, or running around with your furry friends, there's plenty to do in this versatile space. This home also includes an attached 1-car garage and stack-able washer & dryer adding to its convenience and functionality. Centrally located, close to shopping & dining. Don't miss out on this exceptional property - schedule your private tour today before it's gone!

514 Rowlinson Drive, Shirley

$799,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 3547844 MLS
GREAT WATER VIEW FROM EVERY ROOM, TRUE PRIVACY BORDERING NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE. This Spacious Home is Located in Saint George Terrance, a Private Community in South Shirley. This Magnificent Home Showcases Breathtaking Panoramic Water Views and Allows for Plenty of Natural Light Throughout! Offers Over 3,100 Sq Ft of Interior Living Space, this 4 Bedrooms, 3.5 Bathroom Home is a Perfect Choice for the Growing Family. Boasts an Open Floor Plan with a Large Dining Room for Entertaining, Updated Kitchen is Adorned with White Shaker Panel Cabinets, Quartz Counters, Samsung Stainless Steel Appliances ( which includes a Smart Refrigerator) Updated Less than 2 Years Ago, Complete with 2 Generously Sized Primary On Suites Both of which Allow Access Out to 2nd Story Decks. Additional Features Include: Andersen Windows, Wide Plank Wood Flooring on Second Floor, Central Air Conditioning, Solar Panels (Say Goodbye to Hefty Electric Bills), Nest Thermostats, Hi-Hats, Decora Dimmers and the List Goes On. With West-facing Exposure You are Privileged to Bask in the Picturesque Views of the Setting Sun Over the Bellport Bay and the Scenic View of the Changing Seasons. You Can Choose to Take a Stroll on Your Own Private Beach, Enjoy Kayaking or Just Taking A Hike. This Unique Property is Surrounded by 2,500+ Acres of the Wertheim Nature Preserve (which Borders the North-side of this Property) and is a Nature Enthusiasts Slice of Paradise - Your Own Tranquil, Serene and Private Retreat. Whether You Want a Year Round Residence or a Weekend/Summer Get-a-Way, this May Be the Home You are Searching For. Prime Water view Location WITHOUT the Expense of Flood Insurance and to Top it All Off - Amazing Taxes of Just $10,938.51. Don't Wait - Call Today to Schedule Your Own Private Viewing.

34 Hay Road, Shirley

$469,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 3547184 MLS
Welcome to this charming fixer-upper gem nestled in a serene neighborhood! This home presents an incredible opportunity for buyers looking to add their personal touch and make it their own. With a bit of TLC and updates, this property has the potential to shine like never before. As you step inside, you're greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, with ample natural light flooding through the windows. The layout boasts spacious rooms, offering plenty of flexibility to customize the space to your liking. Imagine the possibilities of redesigning the kitchen to create a culinary haven or transforming the living room into a cozy retreat perfect for relaxation and entertaining or an evening by the fire. Outside, the sizable yard provides a blank canvas for landscaping enthusiasts to cultivate their dream garden or create a peaceful outdoor sanctuary. Whether you envision hosting summer barbecues or simply enjoying a quiet morning coffee on the patio, the outdoor space offers endless opportunities for enjoyment. Located in a desirable area with convenient access to schools, parks, and shopping, this home is ideal for buyers seeking a blend of comfort and convenience. Don't miss out on the chance to turn this diamond in the rough into the home of your dreams. With a little imagination and effort, this property has the potential to become the envy of the neighborhood. Don't hesitate to seize this incredible opportunity! Basement has interior and exterior entrances for your convenience. New roof was done on May 7, 2024

5 Schenk Drive, Shirley

Start Your Search

Information Copyright 2024, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.